While I'm still processing and digesting everything from last night, gathering my emotions to make a coherent review, there is something that has been nagging at me for a while regarding Supernatural as presented loud and clear from last night. And I think this sums up my feelings on the situation very nicely:
This has been my issue with Supernatural for a while now, is that there's too much lipservice and not much showing about how the two main characters are learning and growing from their experiences. We can chalk it up saying that they have their own personal issues, but after six seasons you'd think it'd get through their thick skulls and understand where certain characters are coming from instead of being selfish and self-righteous about everything when they've done just about as bad or worse. Surely there's emotion from all sides but the show fails at presenting a clear way of showing that, even after all the things the Winchesters have gone through, what they've witnessed and experienced firsthand, they cannot see outside their own bubble and that's the infuriating part especially after watching last night's episode and seeing the hurt and dismay Castiel was going through, and how they failed at trying to understand his side.
Here in this clip, Lee Adama is actually defending Gaius Baltar when he doesn't remotely like him at all. This is what Lee Adama believes in his heart, and we've seen Lee grow over the course of the series because of this, what he's learned and what he's come to believe despite it all. Pretty much all the characters have gone through a powerful transformation at some point during the series. And guys, Battlestar Galactica had only four seasons. Supernatural has six and we're still dealing with the self-centered immaturity and recycled nonsense the Winchesters deal with. Does that seem right to you?
Now I'm not saying that Supernatural needs to be making epic speeches every episode (although that would be pretty awesome...) they really need to start upping their game at having characters learn something and actually keeping that in their minds for future reference. Don't have them say one thing, then do the opposite in the next episode. Actually giving them character development than just repeating the same shit over and over and never getting anywhere, even if they are totally flawed characters with many issues. Otherwise that's just piss-poor laziness of the writing. :/
Just, yeah. There are many things that irritate me about the show, however that is the major one that brought up my reaction from last night and it just makes no sense how they cannot see this flaw and at least try to eradicate it.
Oh and yes, that is who you think it is in the clip.
This has been my issue with Supernatural for a while now, is that there's too much lipservice and not much showing about how the two main characters are learning and growing from their experiences. We can chalk it up saying that they have their own personal issues, but after six seasons you'd think it'd get through their thick skulls and understand where certain characters are coming from instead of being selfish and self-righteous about everything when they've done just about as bad or worse. Surely there's emotion from all sides but the show fails at presenting a clear way of showing that, even after all the things the Winchesters have gone through, what they've witnessed and experienced firsthand, they cannot see outside their own bubble and that's the infuriating part especially after watching last night's episode and seeing the hurt and dismay Castiel was going through, and how they failed at trying to understand his side.
Here in this clip, Lee Adama is actually defending Gaius Baltar when he doesn't remotely like him at all. This is what Lee Adama believes in his heart, and we've seen Lee grow over the course of the series because of this, what he's learned and what he's come to believe despite it all. Pretty much all the characters have gone through a powerful transformation at some point during the series. And guys, Battlestar Galactica had only four seasons. Supernatural has six and we're still dealing with the self-centered immaturity and recycled nonsense the Winchesters deal with. Does that seem right to you?
Now I'm not saying that Supernatural needs to be making epic speeches every episode (although that would be pretty awesome...) they really need to start upping their game at having characters learn something and actually keeping that in their minds for future reference. Don't have them say one thing, then do the opposite in the next episode. Actually giving them character development than just repeating the same shit over and over and never getting anywhere, even if they are totally flawed characters with many issues. Otherwise that's just piss-poor laziness of the writing. :/
Just, yeah. There are many things that irritate me about the show, however that is the major one that brought up my reaction from last night and it just makes no sense how they cannot see this flaw and at least try to eradicate it.
Oh and yes, that is who you think it is in the clip.
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 12:54 am (UTC)I loved 6.20, though I can understand your frustration with the Winchester's not evolving and learning from their own mistakes. They do tend to get up on their high horse and ride rough shod over anyone who isn't named Sam or Dean with their self righteous retoric.
I sort of think that Dean did stick by Cas in the episode though (assuming they aren't on opposite sides when we see them next) but I'm happy to disagree on that. I am a bit of an eternal optimist when it comes to my favourite characters, so I'm still holding out hope Dean will help Cas somehow.
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 01:15 am (UTC)He did, but it would have been more believable with the impact of everything had we've been shown the supportive attitude from Dean the entire season. Because we've never seen that, Dean has been treating Castiel like shit nearly this whole time and every time Castiel tries to mention his hardships with this war, he just merely dismisses it. So I could get behind the impact more had there been something prior for us to feel bad about Dean feeling a little betrayed by Castiel at this point.
But the reality is, there was nothing there to feel sorry for Dean when he's been an inconsiderate jackass this whole time.
I want to be optimistic that their relationship will be repaired and patched up soon, but it would rely on trust with the writers however I don't trust them aside from Ben Edlund (who rocked this episode out, even if many things didn't match up to the rest of the season at all.) I just wished the show would acknowledge their mistakes because they get called out on it many times, however they just hand-wave it and never address it again. That's lazy writing, imo.
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 06:04 am (UTC)I mean, I think with this season we only had the Bobby-centric episode and this Castiel-centric episode which focused on them, not the Winchesters. More of that, less focus on the Winchesters, or at least integrate it all together as they should be.
Also that clip? So depressing to watch after last nights episode. :(
I know. :( I had thought about that speech after the episode aired last night and when I went to watch it I started crying all over again. Because it's so true to how the boys have been treating Castiel all season. But then again, most of BSG is like that because they call out many things, and you know what? Characters grow from it. I wish SPN was the same.
Then again, BSG is superb television, so....
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 04:21 am (UTC)It may be lazy writing, but mainly I have accepted the Winchester boys' unwilingness (or inability) to learn, and once, just once see things from a different perspective, as an integral part of their flawed characters. As part of the tragic of it all, because they go through that over and over, and still make the same mistakes, because they just can't see.
The only real problem I have with this is that I'm afraid I'm starting to dislike them for it. And that's something that shouldn't happen with the main characters of a show.
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 05:57 am (UTC)After the episode aired, I kept thinking about this clip and it just rings so painfully true. I wished this show would acknowledge these faults and flaws of all the characters in a brave manner.
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 06:03 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 06:07 am (UTC)Castiel deserves better than how they've been treating him all season long.
no subject
Date: 2011-05-09 01:56 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-05-09 02:20 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-05-09 02:25 pm (UTC)Balthazar.
He may not have the full grasp on free will and its consequences, and he may not be able to offer Castiel the kind of support Dean should be offering him. But he loves Castiel, and from everything we have seen of him so far, I'm convinced he will be right there. :)
(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 07:27 am (UTC)I think I'm more hurt over that than anything else. And I can just see Cas still trying to help them because that's what he does. But what's he ever gotten in return? When has he ever ASKED anything in return? And I think it's inevitable that he'll sacrifice himself in some way in the finale. And the Winchesters still won't get it. I guarantee not one tear will be shed. I have no hope that anything will change in S7.
I mean, I don't hate them. But I've said loads of times that the writers outright acknowledge within the episodes that the brothers are being jerks sometime. But they never go anywhere with it. They never let them redeem themselves. Why even bring it up? This season has been especially bad with that.
And whenever it comes to the supporting characters; Booby and Cas, they just drop the ball almost every time. Why can't they understand? I still WANT to love them like I used to, but they make it so hard sometime. Cas has taken over my heart :(
no subject
Date: 2011-05-09 02:04 pm (UTC)I have some hope after last weeks episode, because there finally was some true emotion on Dean's part at least, but still no real attempt to understand where Castiel is coming from, why he HAD to do what he did. Why can't Dean at least try to look at this from a different perspective? Just this once!
I still WANT to love them like I used to, but they make it so hard sometime. Cas has taken over my heart :(
Same here.
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 06:16 am (UTC)It's so funny because I was just thinking to myself how annoying it that the boys still have this black and white morality mindset when dealing when on shows like Buffy The Vampire Slayer and Angel, the main characters start out as black and white and then grow and change and realize that the world is many shades of gray. Nothing is ever simple and clear cut as it seems.
Unfortunately, I am afraid that the Winchesters will never learn this lesson which is more the pity. More the pity.
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 08:03 am (UTC)They really do have a simplistic mindset, despite what they've personally dealt with firsthand. You'd think that would shift and make them evolve, but nope. It hasn't, and after six season they probably never will. It truly is a damn shame because I would have more respect for the show if they addressed these issues more and dealt with them properly.
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 08:35 am (UTC)Yes. All of this.
they cannot see outside their own bubble and that's the infuriating part especially after watching last night's episode and seeing the hurt and dismay Castiel was going through, and how they failed at trying to understand his side.
As much as I love them and I do, this is precisely my issue with them. It's all self-centred anger and hurt and "I don't want to hear it! Just do as I say!" ... Especially from Dean.
I love you dor using this clip. Now i'm going to go back and get into BSG again because it was so awesome.
Also? Does that seem right to you? Nice firefly reference.
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 11:54 am (UTC)I expected more understanding from Dean, however both he and Sam (and shockingly Bobby, as well) shunned Castiel without even hearing his side of the story. I just don't understand why. Granted I'm sure there's hurt from learning the truth, but did they have to go to such extremes? Everything from the holy ring of fire to the angel banishing sigils and even threatening to kill him was a complete overreaction, and I just don't get it.
I wish they would listen for once instead of going off the deep end.
I hate this aspect about them, and being in the sixth season they should know better. Emotions can get the better of them and they overreact, however they should understand Castiel's situation because they have been there before. They have been to that utterly desperate place and did reckless things when they thought it was the only option. I just, gah. :( This is their flaw that they have, but I just can't accept that as an excuse anymore. Because they are grown men, they shouldn't be playing these games anymore.
I love you dor using this clip. Now i'm going to go back and get into BSG again because it was so awesome.
I had to, and besides with BSG they do post-apocalyptic angst right, and these moments, these moments and speeches showing character development, of characters questioning their morality in times of war...this is something I return to when things on Supernatural piss me off.
Also? Does that seem right to you? Nice firefly reference.
Hee. Not gonna lie, when I was writing that I totally thought it in Jubal Early's voice. ;)
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 12:19 pm (UTC)FUCKING THIS! I was shocked when I saw how he didn't even listen. And I agree, and although I can see the need for the circle (keeping Cas in place long enough to hear him out without him flapping off if he didn't want to hear it. I get that.) the sigils and the threats were well out of order. Deans flaw has always been his black and white view of the world but he forgives his brothers discretions so why not his angels? I mean he called him brother and then, in the next breath, threatened him.
It's frustrating but I suppose character growth has to be sacrificed for plot movement at this point.
BSG was a thing of beauty, ngl. It was one of those things that just stands head and shoulders and shows off just what writers can do if they're given free reign. It's a shame the SPN writers aren't allowed the same sort of latitude. Still...let us both go to the happy BSG place.
Jubal Early was amazing. Firefly was amazing. I miss it so...
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 12:56 pm (UTC)See, this is what frustrates me about this show. Too many times they have sacrificed character growth, characterizations, potential storylines just for the sake of getting the season done. They had so many opportunities this season to show Dean actually giving a damn about Castiel, to show there being something more than him and Sam taking advantage of Castiel's unconditional helpfulness and support. Just, they've missed so much and now they are just rushing things along just to get to the end of the season and that's just bullshit to me.
I love BSG, sfm. It's my favorite television series ever, and I'm not exaggerating. It was a perfect example of how epic television should be. Perhaps I've been spoiled because I watch things like BSG and expect shows likes SPN to be the same, therefore I expect too much, idk.
Jubal Early was amazing. Firefly was amazing. I miss it so...
I miss Firefly, too. Another example of great television.
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 11:42 am (UTC)SERIOUSLY. UNLESS THIS IS PURPOSEFULLY DONE TO SHOW HOW IMPULSIVELY STUPID THE WINCHESTERS ARE WITH THEIR RASH ACCUSATIONS AND SHUNNING OUT THOSE WHO THEY DON'T AGREE WITH, HOW COULD DEAN FORGET ALL OF THAT IF HE CONSIDERED CASTIEL NOT JUST A FRIEND BUT PART OF THE FAMILY? HE DIDN'T EVEN LISTEN TO CAS. JUST BANISHED HIM. JUST, WHAT? D: CASTIEL DOESN'T DESERVE THIS. HE DIDN'T DO ANYTHING REMOTELY SO HORRIBLE FOR THEM TO BANISH HIM AND ACT THE WAY THEY DID, WITH THE WARDING SIGILS AND WHATNOT. AND DEAN'S WORDS TO HIM AT THE END, JUST, GODDAMMIT. D: D: D:
YOU'RE RIGHT, IT REALLY TRULY ISN'T FAIR AND I HOPE SOMEONE CALLS THEM OUT ON IT, OTHERWISE.... :(
AND THIS IS WHY I CHOOSE THAT SPEECH SPECIFICALLY. IT'S SO REAL TO WHAT CASTIEL IS GOING THROUGH AND HOW HYPOCRITICAL THE WINCHESTERS ARE BEING. I JUST, YEAH.
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 12:36 pm (UTC)I CAN'T, I CAN'T. ;___;
SLIGHTLY RANDOMLY: Y'KNOW, I DOUBT THE SHOW INTENDED THIS... BUT DEAN BASICALLY OFFERED CASTIEL THE SAME CHOICE RAPHAEL DID AT THE END OF THE EPISODE: SUBMIT OR DIE. :|
OH GOD, HE DID DIDN'T HE? NOW IT REALLY IS A QUESTION WHETHER CASTIEL IS WILLING TO LOSE THIS WAR OR IF HE'S WILLING TO LOSE HIS BOND AND FRIENDSHIP WITH THE WINCHESTERS? D: D: D:
SERIOUSLY, I CAN'T TAKE THIS ANYMORE.
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 01:01 pm (UTC)HE DID. I WANTED TO PUNCH DEAN FOR THAT ALONE. >:|
JUST SERIOUSLY, NO WONDER CASTIEL IS CONFESSING EVERYTHING TO GOD -- WHO MAY OR MAY NOT BE LISTENING -- BECAUSE HE'S GOT NO ONE ELSE TO TURN TO. HE'S AT A CROSSROADS AND IT'S EITHER HE SUBMITS TO ONE SIDE OR HE DOES AND IT'S JUST, OMG CAS! D: D:
PERHAPS THIS IS JUST ME BEING EMOTIONAL, BUT IF THERE WAS ANY CHANCE FOR A FICTIONAL CHARACTER TO BECOME REAL SO WE CAN COMFORT HIM, NOW WOULD BE THE PERFECT TIME. :(
*hugs and comforts our bb angel*
(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 01:04 pm (UTC)WHAT THE FUCK?
(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 12:21 pm (UTC)*SOBS WITH YOU*
SO DRAMATIC TODAY - WHERE IS MY FUCKING FAINTING COUCH?
no subject
Date: 2011-05-09 02:16 pm (UTC)I didn't even think of that any more. That just makes it so much worse. Obviously blanket apologies are either only valid for humans, or they're only valid until Dean decides he's not in the mood any more.
no subject
Date: 2011-05-09 02:24 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-05-09 02:32 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-05-09 02:36 pm (UTC)Hug your angel, don't verbally abuse him, ffs. :/
no subject
Date: 2011-05-09 04:43 pm (UTC)That one, and last week, when he basically called Castiel useless without his powers. That was just cruel, and I really don't know what Dean is thinking or if he is thinking at all.
no subject
Date: 2011-05-10 12:00 am (UTC)(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 11:04 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 11:36 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 11:40 am (UTC)After six seasons, I would have expected the Winchesters to be better than who they first were. I like that they have problems but not when they're always in the same old, same old. It doesn't endear me to them and makes it so incredibly difficult to just simply overlook their flaws and love them just because they're Sam and Dean. I don't want to see them remain the same as they were from past seasons. I want to see them grow and learn, become better persons instead of these self-centered, self-entitled and self-righteous dicks who can't see beyond themselves and their little world.
The writers are also at fault for the Winchesters' inconsistent behaviour.
This ended up being a tl;dr rant. I'm sorry. TAT
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 12:14 pm (UTC)It really has gotten old, their same-old routine of caring only about themselves and their little world instead of looking at the bigger picture of how everything is connected. Even last season, they didn't seem to take the apocalypse seriously until the very end. It just has gotten to the point where it's tiring, where we just don't care about their troubles when there are bigger things happening around them.
I love flawed characters, but remaining flawed and not learning from their mistakes and growing from their experiences is just irritating and makes me unsympathetic towards them. They've become unbearable and unlikeable at this point in the series, and it's just enough already. :|
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 12:49 pm (UTC)They're all a bunch of hypocrites. They were working with demons not so long ago and giving Castiel grief just because he's doing the same? Pot, kettle, black. Don't call someone family when you turn around and say/do things differently to that person.
It's gotten to the point where I have no patience to watch or hear what they have to say or even care about them.
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 01:26 pm (UTC)Unless they realize their faults by the end of the season, I'm done with their bullshit. Just done.
I THINK ILU SO MUCH RIGHT NOW, BB.
Date: 2011-05-08 12:23 pm (UTC)AND A STANDING OVATION:
SERIOUSLY AND I WILL SAY THIS MUCH: THIS NEEDS TO BE POSTED AND REPOSTED EVERYWHERE FOR EVERYONE TO SEE BECAUSE THIS IS JUST GLORIOUS AND NAYSAYERS CAN STFU BECAUSE THIS IS ABSOLUTELY FUCKING TRUE. LEE'S SPEECH + YOU HAVING TO REWRITE IT SO IT FITS WITH THE CASTIEL SITUATION JUST....FITS SO PERFECTLY, PAINFULLY PERFECTLY.
I AM CRYING RIGHT NOW READING IT. LEGIT TEARS.
Re: I THINK ILU SO MUCH RIGHT NOW, BB.
Date: 2011-05-08 12:40 pm (UTC)AND THEN I'D GIVE CASTIEL A HUGE HUG BECAUSE HE NEEDS ONE. MORE THAN ONE. HELL, I'D NEVER LET GO.
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 03:52 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 11:25 pm (UTC)I mean as predictable as the Winchesters have become from their simplistic mindset and stupidity, this episode was pretty amazing and it showed the kind of conflict Castiel was going through and it just was so heartbreaking. I never felt so emotionally connected to a character like I have watching this episode....and it just makes me more angry at the Winchesters for only thinking about themselves instead of others for once.
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 11:35 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 08:39 pm (UTC)I still love you Cas bb. You can use my soul if you want. Forget the winchesters.
no subject
Date: 2011-05-08 11:31 pm (UTC)