It's been nagging at my brain...

[rogueslayer452]

Was Sam really in Hell? Because correct me if I'm wrong, but I got the impression that Lucifer's cage was more of solitary confinement. And even if this was the case, had Sam been telling the truth he wouldn't have been there for as long as Dean had been and definitely not in the same kind of context either, which make his nonsensical argument about their experiences being "different" incredibly invalid.

As for what the hell is wrong with Sam, I think whether or not either Lucifer or Michael is still inhabiting him, Sam has no soul. The concept with souls happen to be an interesting with this show, this season has an example of both demons and angels making deals with humans in exchange for their souls. So that could be one possibility. There's also something to take into account that was mentioned back in S2 when YED had been talking with Dean about whether or not Sam had returned "right"; granted it could have just been a manipulative ploy because hey, demon. But we've seen Sam go from being Sammy to being this douchebag with a chip on his shoulder since then, so I'm wondering what if there's any significance to that statement or if I'm just reaching for something to make sense from the mess we've been getting lately.


New episode tonight, so hopefully we'll find out.

I'm sorry y'all, I'm still very upset about Caprica, that's what's been on my mind lately. I hate to even suggest it, but Syfy has treated Caprica like how FOX treated Firefly, and it depresses and pisses me off. ;__;

Comments

[high-flyer87.livejournal.com]

With them introducing the whole "angels can take souls too" idea, I definitely think we're dealing with a misplaced soul here. Whether he sold it or if Lucifer's just keeping it nice and warm for him, idk.

Lucifer is an angel after all.

I say, he either called keeps on Sam's soul, or Sam traded it in exchange for freedom.

But this whole Sam in Hell thing has really bothered me from the get-go. His experience was technically was different from Dean's--drastically so, if we're taking his word that he was only down there for a very short amount of time, plus the fact that Lucifer's cage is completely different from the General Admission section of Hell. There's just something so dodgy about it all. And I'm tired of the goddamn secrets. I think it's time to spill the beans and let us know what's going on. Otherwise...I will lose interest.

[rogueslayer452.livejournal.com]

I think sometimes people forget that Lucifer is an angel, and a very manipulative one at that; he's able to get underneath your skin and really try and connect with you, so there's definitely a high possibility that whatever happened Sam made a deal with Lucifer in exchange for that freedom and maybe he doesn't even remember. Or that he does, he's just lying straight through his teeth.

The whole thing about him being in Hell is definitely dodgy, and I hope they don't drag it out with all these secrets because the entire thing of ~~Sam is keeping sekrits from Dean~~ has been overdone. Just let us know what is going on and move on with that, okay show? I've lost interest in the entire thing since the premiere because I knew they were rehashing it all over again.

Move forward, not backwards.